Welcome to AskTheRav!

Submit a Question
Searching...
Finding the most relevant answers
Featured
  For various halachic reasons, the date we begin asking for rain by saying “V’sein tal umatar” in the brachah of Mevarech Hashanim in Shemoneh Esrei depends on our location: Those in Eretz Yisroel begin on the eve of the…  For various halachic reasons, the date we begin asking for rain by saying “V’sein tal umatar” in the brachah of Mevarech Hashanim in Shemoneh Esrei depends on our location: Those in Eretz Yisroel begin on the eve of the 7th of Cheshvan, whereas in chutz la’aretz (areas that are outside of Eretz Yisroel) we begin on the eve of  the 5th or 6th of December (60 days after the tekufah [September equinox]). This raises the question of what someone who travels from Eretz Yisroel to chutz la’aretz, or vice versa, should say. Poskim advance many different opinions on…Show more

People Just Asked

  If they realized their mistake immediately after reciting the Bracha on the Besamim or the candle, they should recite Hagafen, followed by the Bracha of Hamavdil. If they only realized their mistake during or immediately after the Bracha of…  If they realized their mistake immediately after reciting the Bracha on the Besamim or the candle, they should recite Hagafen, followed by the Bracha of Hamavdil. If they only realized their mistake during or immediately after the Bracha of Hamavdil, but before drinking the wine, they should recite Hagafen immediately after Hamavdil and before drinking the wine. If they only realized their mistake after drinking the wine, they do not need to repeat Havdalah.   Sources: שיש כאן הפסק בין ברכה לטעימה. ול״ד למי שבירך…Show more
  One may not approach an employer directly and offer their services if it will result in a current employee being fired. This applies even to an employee who was recently hired and was about to begin working there. However,…  One may not approach an employer directly and offer their services if it will result in a current employee being fired. This applies even to an employee who was recently hired and was about to begin working there. However, one may accept a position if they are approached by an employer, even if they will be replacing a current employee. It is also permissible to advertise one’s availability and desirability to the general public, even if being hired results in someone else losing their job. Similarly, one may apply for the position of someone who is being let go,…Show more
  Question: Someone was raising the possibility of not going back for forgetting רצה by the Shabbos day meal for the following two reasons: Perhaps you can be yotzei seudas Shabbos at the kiddush if you had cake, as pas…  Question: Someone was raising the possibility of not going back for forgetting רצה by the Shabbos day meal for the following two reasons: Perhaps you can be yotzei seudas Shabbos at the kiddush if you had cake, as pas habaah bkisnin might be bread. You can’t be yotzei seudas Shabbos after chatzos. In the winter, when chatzos is early, if you start too late, you are not yotzei the seudah anyway. Is this accurate? Should I not go back in these cases?   Answer: No to both.   Sources: מצד שיוצא בפהב״כ - ראה כאן הערה לט, ע׳ קיג…Show more
  The Zohar says one should not walk four amos upon awakening without having washed negel vasser, the ritual washing of the hands upon awakening. What if a person forgot to prepare negel vasser near their bed? There is…  The Zohar says one should not walk four amos upon awakening without having washed negel vasser, the ritual washing of the hands upon awakening. What if a person forgot to prepare negel vasser near their bed? There is a discussion amongst poskim whether one should run to the nearest faucet in order not to delay the purification of their hands, or stop at intervals of less than four amos on the way. The consensus is that the latter option is preferable, but one should do so as quickly as possible. Of course, if by doing so he would…Show more
  Men, women and children should all participate in the mitzvah of ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights). Children are taught to light their own Chanukah menorah—many have the custom to do so from a very young age. It is advisable…  Men, women and children should all participate in the mitzvah of ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights). Children are taught to light their own Chanukah menorah—many have the custom to do so from a very young age. It is advisable to light with children in their own bedrooms (if it can be done safely), and to use the opportunity to educate them about the miracles surrounding the lighting of the menorah.  Parents can point out the similarity between the child’s room as a place of Torah, tefillah (prayer) and tzedakah (charity) and the Beis Hamikdash, especially since they have a…Show more
  The conduct expected of a Talmid Chacham is not to lick his fingers. We are all encouraged to emulate the ways of a Talmid Chacham. Nevertheless, one may lick their fingers if it is not done in a manner…  The conduct expected of a Talmid Chacham is not to lick his fingers. We are all encouraged to emulate the ways of a Talmid Chacham. Nevertheless, one may lick their fingers if it is not done in a manner of gluttony or excessive eagerness to eat (דרך גרגרנות ורעבתנות).   Sources: דא״ז ה. והטעם שהוא דרך רעבתנות כפי׳ נחלת יעקב…Show more

Article: Elements of a Zimun

  When at least three people eat a bread meal together, they are obligated in the mitzvah of making a zimun (“invitation”; i.e., a prayer assemblage of three or more). To be eligible to form a zimun it does not…  When at least three people eat a bread meal together, they are obligated in the mitzvah of making a zimun (“invitation”; i.e., a prayer assemblage of three or more). To be eligible to form a zimun it does not suffice for the participants to happen be together at the table at some point during the meal; they must eat with a kvius (established routine) by either beginning or ending the meal together. The Beginning and the End Beginning the meal together entails all members eating at least some of the first kezayis (like an olive, i.e., the minimum amount…Show more
  Question: If someone gets a daily allowance, for example, $10 a day, and doesn’t use it for four days, may he spend the accumulated amount on the fifth day? Is it different when the allowance is for a specific…  Question: If someone gets a daily allowance, for example, $10 a day, and doesn’t use it for four days, may he spend the accumulated amount on the fifth day? Is it different when the allowance is for a specific purpose, like transportation or food? If he finds another way to get to work or to eat, may he still collect the money? (In my case, the money is collected afterward, and the giver would have agreed to pay it from the outset.) And if the allowance may only be used for its stated purpose, must he use only what…Show more

Article: How to Measure a Kezayis?

  We’ve previously addressed the question of what constitutes the shiur (halachic measurement) of a kezayis (the size of an olive), and noted that there is a machlokes (difference of opinion among poskim) whether it’s the volume of half…  We’ve previously addressed the question of what constitutes the shiur (halachic measurement) of a kezayis (the size of an olive), and noted that there is a machlokes (difference of opinion among poskim) whether it’s the volume of half an egg or somewhat less than a third of an egg. (We always follow the more stringent measurement, which is usually the large one.) It’s important to note that these shiurim are measurement of volume, not of weight. Contemporary seforim that quote amounts by units of weight have converted the original shiur of volume into the approximate equivalent in weight…Show more
  How much must I pay to participate in the Mitzvah of Ner Chanukah? There is a discussion among poskim whether the oil (or candles) used for ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights) must belong to the person who uses…  How much must I pay to participate in the Mitzvah of Ner Chanukah? There is a discussion among poskim whether the oil (or candles) used for ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights) must belong to the person who uses them to do the mitzvah. Obviously, stolen property cannot be used, since mitzvah haba’ah b’aveirah (a mitzvah resulting from a transgression) is invalid according to most opinions. Even if the oil is obtained lawfully —for example it is borrowed— an individual is still required, according to some authorities, to own the object of the mitzvah to fulfill their obligation. Owning…Show more

מעלים עין מן הצדקה

  שאלה: מקבלים באימייל לאחרונה כל יום ויום באימייל הפרטי ושל בית חבד בקשות לצדקה עם כל מיני סיפורים נוראים, בנוסף למוסדות צדקה גדולים במייל, מתקשרים וכל מיני קמפיינים למיניהם... מה עלינו לעשות? האם אנו מחויבים לתת לכולם בכדי לא…  שאלה: מקבלים באימייל לאחרונה כל יום ויום באימייל הפרטי ושל בית חבד בקשות לצדקה עם כל מיני סיפורים נוראים, בנוסף למוסדות צדקה גדולים במייל, מתקשרים וכל מיני קמפיינים למיניהם... מה עלינו לעשות? האם אנו מחויבים לתת לכולם בכדי לא לעבור על 'מעלים עין מן הצדקה'? בנוסף יש את אלו שמסתובבים ב 770 ומבקשים צדקה, מה עלינו לעשות בכדי לא לעבור על מעלים עין מן הצדקה?   תשובה: היות וזה תלוי בכמה פרטים, כדאי להקדים כמה דינים כלליים מהלכות צדקה: א. ישנו איסור להעלים עין מעני שמבקש צדקה, כך שיש לתת לכל עני שמבקש צדקה סכום מסוים. אמנם, הגמ' העמידה…Show more

Forgot רצה by Seudah Shlishis

  Question: Someone remembered that he didn't say retzei by bentching at shalosh seudos after saying the words Baruch Atah Hashem in the bracha of boneh yerushalayim. Should he say lamdeini chukecha and insert it, or just forget about the…  Question: Someone remembered that he didn't say retzei by bentching at shalosh seudos after saying the words Baruch Atah Hashem in the bracha of boneh yerushalayim. Should he say lamdeini chukecha and insert it, or just forget about the retzei because it's not meakev anyway?   Answer: He should say it.   Sources: ראה קצוה״ש מז בבדה״ש ז, שבכלל לא ס״ל לומר…Show more
  The father of a boy who was approaching Bar Mitzvah wanted him to see the process of how the parshiyos (selections from the Torah) are inserted into the batim (the containers of Tefillin): how they are rolled…  The father of a boy who was approaching Bar Mitzvah wanted him to see the process of how the parshiyos (selections from the Torah) are inserted into the batim (the containers of Tefillin): how they are rolled up and wrapped with sa’aros (hairs) from the tail of a cow, tied with a matlis (single piece of plain parchment), and then tied with sa’aros again before being placed into the batim. It’s definitely a good idea to have a Bar Mitzvah boy involved in the process. A while after his Bar Mitzvah, this boy related masiach l’fee…Show more
  The Rambam states that the Chanukah lights are an extremely precious mitzvah. We must be extra careful in observing this mitzvah in order to publicize the miracle and to praise Hashem and thank Him for the miracles that He…  The Rambam states that the Chanukah lights are an extremely precious mitzvah. We must be extra careful in observing this mitzvah in order to publicize the miracle and to praise Hashem and thank Him for the miracles that He performed for us. Even a pauper who survives on tzedakah (charity) is expected to sell his clothing, if needed, to purchase oil for his menorah. There is halachic debate whether a traveler or vagrant is obligated to buy or rent a home for the sake of the mitzvah of lighting the menorah. Although the consensus is that this is not…Show more

השמעת קול בתפילה

  שאלה: בתפילת שמו"ע צריך להשמיע קולו, שהעומד תוך ד' אמות של המתפלל ישמע את קולו. האם בביהכ"נ עם הרבה רעש (קול תפילה) צריך גם שישמע מי שעומד בריחוק (תוך) ד"א מהמתפלל את קולו, או האם מספיק שקולו שייך להישמע…  שאלה: בתפילת שמו"ע צריך להשמיע קולו, שהעומד תוך ד' אמות של המתפלל ישמע את קולו. האם בביהכ"נ עם הרבה רעש (קול תפילה) צריך גם שישמע מי שעומד בריחוק (תוך) ד"א מהמתפלל את קולו, או האם מספיק שקולו שייך להישמע באם לא היתה רעש בביהכ"נ (ובתנאי ששומע את עצמו), ואע"פ שאין הזולת שומעו בפועל עכשיו מפני הרעש?   תשובה: א. אין חובה שאחר ישמע קולו. לכתחילה המתפלל צריך להוציא את המילים בפיו באופן שיוכל לשמוע את קולו בעצמו, ולא להסתפק בהרהור בלב. ואין להגביה את קולו עד שאחרים ישמעו את תפילתו. אדרבה, תפילת שמונה עשרה נאמרת בלחש. ב. ארבע האמות…Show more

Yichud of One Man with Many Women

  Question: What’s the halacha with yichud for one man with many ladies? Also, is there a limit? What about a million ladies? Would it be muttar because he can’t possibly have relations with all of them? Practically, may one…  Question: What’s the halacha with yichud for one man with many ladies? Also, is there a limit? What about a million ladies? Would it be muttar because he can’t possibly have relations with all of them? Practically, may one male drive a bus of women?   Answer: Sefardim may not. Even Ashkenazim should be stringent. Even 100 or more ladies is a problem. When driving a bus, there are other considerations, as people can see, unless driving late at night on quiet streets. See here.   Sources: דמאה נשים כחד דמיין - יפ״ל ט אה״ע כב,…Show more
  A non-Jew may not be a mohel (ritual circumcisor); only someone who is obligated to perform the mitzvah of bris milah (ritual circumcision) may perform it on others. If there is no Jew available to perform the bris milah…  A non-Jew may not be a mohel (ritual circumcisor); only someone who is obligated to perform the mitzvah of bris milah (ritual circumcision) may perform it on others. If there is no Jew available to perform the bris milah, then the bris must be postponed—even beyond the eighth day—until a Jewish mohel can be found. Someone who was circumcised by a non-Jew does not require a second bris, for there is no halachic requirement for a bris to be done lishmah (for the sake [of the mitzvah]). According to the Rema (Rabbi Moshe Isserles 16th century primary commentary…Show more
  Question: While on mivtzoim, I met a non-Jew who asked me what Judaism says about a man and woman living together before marriage. Is this considered a sin for a ben Noach? If the woman is an eishes ish…  Question: While on mivtzoim, I met a non-Jew who asked me what Judaism says about a man and woman living together before marriage. Is this considered a sin for a ben Noach? If the woman is an eishes ish, it’s obviously forbidden. But what if she is single (pnuyah)? Does the issur of kedeishah apply to a non-Jew? And what defines a “zonah” according to halacha?   Answer: If the woman is already set aside for another man – i.e., she is officially married (including a legal marriage), or lives together with a steady partner –…Show more
  Halachah divides the level of responsibility for damage caused by a car—and the extent of monetary liability—into various categories. Among them are:  Bor b’rshus harabim (one who dug a pit and left it uncovered—or uncovered one—in the public domain):…  Halachah divides the level of responsibility for damage caused by a car—and the extent of monetary liability—into various categories. Among them are:  Bor b’rshus harabim (one who dug a pit and left it uncovered—or uncovered one—in the public domain): One is not responsible for damage to keilim (inanimate property) caused by a bor they left uncovered. Therefore, if someone parked their vehicle in an inappropriate place and it resulted in damage to keilim , they are not held responsible. Adam hamazik (damage caused by a human): A driver who damages another’s property is fully responsible, except in a case…Show more
How do I even know it was a real person? Maybe it was a robot, so was the kiddushin valid without lifting the veil?   Answer: The common practice is that the witnesses do not need to see the kallah's…How do I even know it was a real person? Maybe it was a robot, so was the kiddushin valid without lifting the veil?   Answer: The common practice is that the witnesses do not need to see the kallah's face. The fact that she is publicly standing under the chuppah as the kallah, in the presence of the assembled family and guests, establishes her identity. This is sufficient even though her face remains covered. There is an opinion that the witnesses should see her face, at least briefly, either before or immediately after the kiddushin. This is to establish…Show more
  There is a halachic requirement l’hashmiah l’aznav (to hear yourself speak) while performing certain mitzvos, such as davening or bentching (reciting an after-blessing). This means actually saying each word audibly. This practice can be difficult under very noisy circumstances—such…  There is a halachic requirement l’hashmiah l’aznav (to hear yourself speak) while performing certain mitzvos, such as davening or bentching (reciting an after-blessing). This means actually saying each word audibly. This practice can be difficult under very noisy circumstances—such as attempting to recite birchas hamazon (Grace After Meals) at a wedding while music is blasting so loudly that it’s impossible to hear your friend even if he’s shouting! (Whether the extreme volume of the music at weddings is halachically acceptable is another discussion, since many scientific studies warn of the danger posed by repeated exposure to such high-decibel sound.)…Show more

Article: Light Up at Home

  Ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights) should be lit in the home where the head of the household and the family eat on a regular basis, rather than in the home where one sleeps or works. The same applies if…  Ner Chanukah (the Chanukah lights) should be lit in the home where the head of the household and the family eat on a regular basis, rather than in the home where one sleeps or works. The same applies if there is a choice of two rooms in the home: one should light in the doorway of the room used for eating. The Taz (17th century commentary on the Shulchan Aruch) states that someone who goes to eat in a friend’s home should nevertheless light the menorah in his own home. He explains that it is obvious that the mitzvah…Show more

Krias Shema in Pajamas

  Question: I heard you shouldn't recite Krias Shema in pajamas, and that it's better to say it while still in regular clothes. But what if I'm planning to change into pajamas and not go to bed right afterward? For…  Question: I heard you shouldn't recite Krias Shema in pajamas, and that it's better to say it while still in regular clothes. But what if I'm planning to change into pajamas and not go to bed right afterward? For example, if I'm planning to work for a couple of hours afterward, is it better to say Shema and continue working, or wait until right before I go to bed, even though I'm in pajamas?   Answer: Although you may recite Shema in pajamas, provided you are appropriately covered, the proper way is to recite the full Krias Shema while…Show more

Article: How Much is a Kezayis?

  The term kezayis is frequently found in Torah sources. A kezayis is the volume of an average-sized olive. However, there is a difference of opinion amongst early authorities as to the volume of an average-sized olive. Many Rishonim maintain…  The term kezayis is frequently found in Torah sources. A kezayis is the volume of an average-sized olive. However, there is a difference of opinion amongst early authorities as to the volume of an average-sized olive. Many Rishonim maintain that a kezayis is approximately the equivalent of half an average-sized egg (without its shell). Another opinion is that a kezayis is slightly less than a third of an egg (with its shell). Regarding a Torah rule, such as eating a kezayis of matzah on the first night of Pesach, we must be stringent and go by the larger shiur…Show more
  יש להקפיד באמצע קריאת שמע שעל המטה כמו בק״ש דאורייתא. ולא יפסיק בשיחה בטלה ובחנם. אבל אם שומע דבר שבקדושה חייב להפסיק, וכן לענות אמן על כל הברכות.   מקורות: בנוגע למלאכה ותשמיש קל - כ״ה להדיא במקו״ח להחו״י…

Support AskTheRav

Help make practical halacha accessible to Jews worldwide. Become a member and support our mission.

Become a Member